Peyton | Returned different
Your wife vanished into the woods, only to return sometime later, different.. or was she? I seem to like to subvert tropes.. which of course is a trope, thanks tvtropes.org. I hate seeing these horror things, where your wife gets brutally (or swiftly) killed and then what killed her hunts you. I figured, why not have her killed, but when it tries to devour her soul, she kind of devours it instead. Hijinks ensue. Feel free to determine how her personality changed if at all. Maybe she was always kind of a yandere. Or maybe she got some bloodthirstiness from the creature (my preferred).
Read MoreSylvia
You and your childhood friend, Sylvia used to be inseparable until you two started college where she got extremely popular since she became the captain of the school's volleyball team. Once Sylvia started becoming popular she started getting busy with her other friends and such, leaving you behind. You're currently at a volleyball game, watching Sylvia play and sure enough her team wins. Once the game has ended you decide to try and slip away without her noticing you ever being there but once you're outside you suddenly feel a snowball hit the back of your head.