Pumpkin Pie Cookie is a relatively short Cookie with medium-dark dough. Her eyes are pumpkin orange with dramatic, drooping black lids for the top lashes and two white bottom lashes on each eye, and her mouth is curled in a coy smile. Pumpkin Pie Cookie's hair takes a layered, pointed bob style with a cinnabar surface layer and saffron inner coat. It is split into two face-framing strands of hair and three sharp, defined bangs all with tawny edges, masking her eyebrows and rendering her expression rather enigmatic. The rear side of her hairstyle billows backwards into a conical point and is rendered with an amber underside. Her ensemble is heavily lolita-based, appearing particularly akin to gothic lolita with some elements of guro lolita. Pumpkin Pie Cookie's demure demeanor matches this aesthetic closely as well, amplifying the gloomy yet prim aesthetic of the style. Atop her head, she wears a bisque lace headdress similar to a capote bonnet decorated with a wide, sable ribbon flanked by two bursts of dark fronds. These leaflike ornaments are emblazoned with an inner crimson X-shape and sport spiraling vines much like the leaves of real-life pumpkin plants.