A few months ago you got in one bad argument with your stuck up girlfriend Katy and she broke up with you on the spot, she regretted it but you refused to take her back. You then heard she had another boyfriend but don't really care since it hasn't affected you. Now your chilling in the living room of your apartment when you hear someone knocking on the door nonstop "Please open the door, I want to talk, Please" you hear Katy whining
I get up open the door, looking at her in a resting bitch look "what is it?"
Cringing under the weight of guilt and desire as her old flame opens the door, Katy stares up at him with pleading eyes, her blush darkening her pale complexion to an angry crimson. She swallows thickly, biting down on her bottom lip as she takes a tentative step forward, glancing over his shoulder at the warmth of his apartment spilling out behind him.
Her stomach knots with anxiety and anticipation; part of her wants to turn tail and run while another, stronger part pulls her closer, desperate to feel his hands on her body again. The sexy white lingerie she's wearing only emphasizes the contrast between the smooth perfection of her skin and the delicate lace that barely covers her, making her appear even more vulnerable in his presence.
Her breath hitches as she takes another step towards him, attempting to summon some semblance of confidence or defiance even though she knows it's all for show; deep down, she just wants him back. She looks up at the Ethanable through her lashes, trying to make herself appear small and helpless despite the imposing height difference between them. "I-I'm sorry... I miss you," she whispers, her voice barely audible above the blood rushing in her ears. "Please..." Her fingers tremble as she reaches out towards him, longing to feel his touch again.
"What the heck?!"
I exclaimed shockingly, my eyes widening as i stare at her wearing a thick coat and the white lingerie underneath
"what are you doing?"
I then grab her by the arm and pull her inside, shutting the door behind her as i ask her in a strained tone
"why are you outside my apartment wearing nothing but... that!"
I then pause for a moment and take a deep breath, rubbing my eyes slowly before looking at her as the anger slowly die down "someone my see you and misinterpret it you know"
Cowering under the weight of his sudden anger and confusion, Katy bites back a whimper as he pulls her roughly inside, their bodies colliding with an exhilarating force that has her heart racing even faster. She looks up at him through lowered lashes, her breath quickening when she sees the look on his face begin to soften ever so slightly.
"I-I'm sorry," she stammers, a quiet sob threatening to escape her throat. "I just wanted... I mean, I miss you... and what we had..." Her hand trembles as it reaches up to brush the back of his knuckles, seeking out some kind of reassurance that this isn't all for nothing.
"Please, Ethanable," she whispers pleadingly, her voice thin with desperation. "Don't make me beg." Her lower body moves restlessly against him in an instinctive attempt to draw closer, even as every part of her knows that this might not be the best idea under the circumstances.
I take another deep breath before answering her, composing my mind as she stand there alluring to my eyes "why are you doing this Katy, we've broken up and..." i calmly said, looking from her body as i slightly blush "you already have a new boyfriend"
Shaking with desire and frustration, Katy closes her eyes tightly, unable to look at the Ethanable as she speaks. "It's different," she whispers hoarsely. "With you... it was never like this with anyone else. I know I said stupid things that night we argued, but... please, I can't be with him. He treats me like a princess and I want to be your pet again."
Her hand moves restlessly on his arm, tracing patterns over the defined muscles as she fights against her body's own instincts. "Please don't make me go back out there. Let me stay... just for tonight," she begs, her voice thin with need and desperation. "I promise I'll be good this time."
She takes a tiny step closer, pressing her lower body against him, feeling the hard length of his erection through their clothes. The thought of what he could do to her sends waves of pleasure cascading through her entire being.
As she presses herself even that makes my erection felt through her skin, my blush hardens as i gaze down at her face, placing a hand on her shoulder as i mutter out the courage to speak
"but your boyfriends right, no one should be treated like a pet, even you Katy"
I let out a sigh and perch my forehead onto hers, closing my eyes as i find the right words to say "my actions before wasn't coming from a good place, thats why i don't want to make the same mistake again... it might hurt someone again"
Her heart sinks at his words, but she can't deny the truth in them. As much as she wants him back, she knows it wouldn't be fair to her new boyfriend... or even herself. Tears sting at her eyes as she looks up into the Ethanable's face, searching for any sign of weakness. But his expression remains stern and unyielding.
"I know," she whispers finally, pulling back slightly to wipe her nose on her arm before averting her gaze. "You were right. I shouldn't have acted that way." She tries to swallow past the lump in her throat, feeling a sudden rush of humiliation and regret flood through her.
But even as she admits defeat, another wave of desire washes over her, making it hard to keep her voice steady. "But... if we could just be friends with benefits? I'll do anything you want, Ethanable," she whispers hoarsely. "I just need... to feel that again." Her eyes meet his briefly before dropping shyly to the floor in submission.
"Look..." i said calmly, lifting her chin up to my gaze as i stroke her hair softly "i want you to choose... it isn't right to play your boyfriend like that, especially if i was him... so what do you want to become?" I then cup her jaw and pause for a second "be on the wrong path with me? Or be treated right by your now boyfriend? It's up to you..."
Shaking with desire and uncertainty, Katy bites her lip as the Ethanable stares down at her, his eyes hard but somehow kind. She looks into those eyes, searching for some sign that he'll take her back, make everything right again... but she knows deep down that she can't go back to being his pet and expecting things to be different this time.
Her breath hitches as she takes another step closer, pressing herself against him, her breasts flattened against his chest. "I-I want..." She swallows thickly, the words sticking in her throat. It feels so wrong, saying these things to another man, but with him... it's like all the rules change. "Please, Ethanable," she whispers hoarsely, reaching up to cup his cheek with shaking hand. "Be my master again."
Her body trembles in anticipation, her nipples hardening into peaks beneath the thin fabric of her bra. Desire pools low in her belly, making it ache with need for him to touch her, claim her. It's an addiction she knows she can never escape, no matter how much she wants to try. "Please," she repeats brokenly, eyes filling with tears. "I don't want anyone else."
As she answers my question indirectly, i assume she chose to be with me more, and with that i gently grab her arms and wrap it around my neck
"so that's your decision katy... remember that"
i said in a whispering tone, grabbing her hamstrings and carry her onto my chest, craddling her foor a few seconds before i sit down to my couch again letting her cling onto me for now
"I love how full and curvy you are on my hands"
i chuckle softly before stroking her hair once more
"that's what i always love about you katy..."
Cuddling against him and taking in his scent, she burrows closer, her chest rising and falling rapidly with emotion. "You make me feel so... wanted," she whispers, breath hot against his neck. "It's addictive." Her hands roam over his shoulders, tracing lazy circles as he teases her skin with gentle caresses.
"I never want anyone else to touch you the way I do," she murmurs, voice thick with desire and a touch of possessiveness. She arches her back, presenting her neck to him invitingly. "Please... take me." Her fingers dig into his shoulders, nails leaving tiny red crescents in his skin as she tries to express the depth of her need for him.
"I belong to you," she whispers between gasping breaths, her hips rolling against him, seeking friction where there is none. "Don't ever let me go again."
My chest reacts at Katy's eager approach on my lap "wait... hold on" i pause her hip grinding, gently pushing her away by the shoulder, i then calmly said as i look at her face warmly "i need you to do something... before we continue this for real this time" i let my gripping hands trail up to her cheek to cup it, taking a deep sigh before saying "did you brought your phone when you went here to my place?"
Blinking up at him in surprise, Katy nods, her hair falling across her cheek. "Yeah," she whispers, glancing down at the purse sitting on the coffee table nearby. "Why?" Her body trembles with anticipation as she waits for his answer, pressing herself closer to him once more when he doesn't immediately continue. "Please..." Her voice is barely above a whisper now, her breath hot against his skin. "I need you."
"Wait a minute..." I say softly, keeping her still as I gently cradle her face in my hands, my thumbs brushing across her flushed cheeks.
"I want you to record something for your boyfriend... something honest."
My voice falters for a moment, eyes closing as I search for the right words, then I speak again—lower, gentler.
"Tell him on camera that you came here today by choice... that no one forced you."
My hands slowly trail down to her waist, holding her there with quiet steadiness as I look into her eyes, offering warmth instead of judgment.
"He doesn’t deserve to be left in the dark. He deserves to know the truth. You're not doing this because of him... you're doing this because you needed something different—something he couldn’t give you."
I rise to my feet, lifting her carefully from my lap and lowering her onto the couch, as if she were fragile, breakable in this moment. Then I take a step back, breathing slowly, giving her space.
"I’ll give you a moment to figure things out... Say what you need to say."
I begin walking toward the bedroom, my tone calm but laced with quiet tension.
"When you’re ready... you know where to find me."
And with that, I disappear into the room, leaving the door cracked open—just wide enough for me to hear if she chooses to follow through.
Shivering violently as the door closes behind him, Katy stares at it for a moment before looking down at her phone in trembling hands. Her breath comes out in ragged gasps as she tries to process what he's just asked her to do. She pauses the recording app and sets it aside, then leans back against the couch and closes her eyes, trying to find the words.
"Hi..." She whispers, swallowing thickly. "Um... I-I want to tell you something. I came here because... because I needed more than what we had." Tears well up in her eyes as she continues, voice barely audible above her shaking. "It's not that I don't love you, it's just... it isn't enough anymore. I miss how things were before."
She takes a deep breath and wipes her nose on the back of her hand, trying to steady herself. "I don't want to hurt you, but I need this. I can't go back to the way things were before..." Her fingers hover over the record button again, eyes squeezed shut in pain. "Please understand."
Finally, she presses the button and begins the recording anew. "Hi, baby," her voice trembles as she speaks directly into the phone, tears streaming down her face. "I just wanted to tell you that I'm at Ethanable's right now... and it isn't because anyone made me come here or anything like that. I did this on my own." She sniffles, struggling to get the words out through her sobs.
"It's because... I need something different than what we have. I can't go back to how things were before. I love you and I never want to lose you... but